when the man comes around

This blog post has very little to do with photography. Also, it is very long.

This has not been an easy week.

On January 15, my knee was hit by a car when I was crossing the street near my house. It wasn’t a hard hit and I walked it off, only to decide for going to the ER an hour later, because the knee was swelling and stiffening up. I had an avulsion fracture; the outer ligament had pulled away from the joint, taking a small chip of bone with it.

On Monday, nine days after my knee had been hit, we went to the MU Orthopedic Clinic to check up on everything. The swelling had gone down a remarkable amount; I could see the bumps of my kneecap again, and the bruising had faded away.  I went to get an MRI to double check the injury, and was told that nothing adverse had happened to my other ligaments–my ACL and PCL, which was what I had been worried about. The joint had been pushed in a little bit, but not enough that it too wouldn’t heal up.

I left the MRI place amazed by the resilience of my body and how well it was healing. I knew the initial hit could have been infinity times worse than it had been, but I liked the idea of my knee holding up to the titan of the SUV that hit me. We were winning, somehow. Man over machine.

And as I was in this state of mind, marveling at the intricacies that would heal my knee and get me back to 100 percent again, the intricacies that kept my grandfather’s heart going failed him. He was seventy-one, two and a half months shy of his birthday.

I thought of death as a process. My great-grandparents had passed away after months and years of slowly fading. There was no shock there. They were nonogenarians. That, I thought, was when people were supposed to move on. It made sense.

(my cousin, not me)

Nothing about this makes sense. In the back of my head I know that life is transient and apt to flame out without warning. And I know that my Papa was far from being in the best of health. But it makes no sense in my brain. I couldn’t make the words come out of my mouth when I called my best friend, the family’s honorary granddaughter, to tell her, and finally choked them into the receiver. I felt wrong saying ‘passed away’. There was no slow, gentle passing here, no softening of the blow. There was no other term for it but the worst and harshest, and this was the one that didn’t make sense to me. Papa died. It doesn’t even make sense written out. It makes me cry when I see it and when I say it.

The rational part of me knows how lucky I am, because for some people grandparents are ancillary characters in the play of life. Maybe they send a birthday cards or come for the occasional holiday.

But I had twenty-three years of my grandfather believing in me and supporting me in everything I did. How can you doubt anything when your grandfather tells you with ultimate certainty in his voice that everything’s going to work out?  That nagging hole of self-doubt that drove me crazy on a regular basis was always temporarily filled when I talked to Papa. His security became mine. I believed in me because he did. Of course I had other support systems, my parents chief among them, but somehow it was different hearing encouragement from Papa.

He took me to my first and only NFL game, when Jake the Snake still played for Arizona, and to my first…and second…and third…and so on…basketball games. We saw Barkley, Stockton, and Malone, and Shaq when he was a Laker. We saw Nash duke it out against Chris Paul, and we saw the Gorilla catch serious air as he dunked the ball between quarters.  We went to a few Diamondbacks games when my vacations actually lined up with baseball season, and started going to spring training games two years ago. My parents went with Papa to see Michael Jordan play baseball in the minors. I wish I’d been at that game, but I was young and opted for staying home to play and to read my new books we had just bought at the Narnes and Boble in town.

He played a mean game of Monopoly and never let me or my cousins win. We had to earn it. He played Monopoly Junior with me for a few years, patiently sitting through the easy version until I could make it in the big leagues. His strategy was the same in each game, which didn’t stop him from bankrupting everybody anyway. It got to be a longer process when we got older, but, for the most part, ended the same way.

He took us to the Phoenix Zoo more times than I can count, and last spring, when I visited for spring break, we went back again, just the two of us, for old-times sake. We spent extra time at the coatimundi exhibit–my favorite–and at the Arabian oryxs–his favorite. He introduced me to Johnny Cash and Roy Orbison, and listened happily when I told him about seeing Chuck Berry in concert. He drank Diet Coke, described tofu as tasting like bathing cap, and still made sure I had Tofurkey when I visited for Thanksgiving.

But there was always the problem of he and my stepgrandmother living in Arizona, far away from the rest of us. For years, my aunt and her family lived in Seattle and visited often. They moved to New England when my own family did, and suddenly everybody but Papa and Kathy was on the East Coast. My cousins and I didn’t have the flexible schedules we’d had before. Arizona vacation times trickled off.

We went to Cape Cod instead.

I could fill a Joycean-length book writing about Cape Cod. It was Papa and Kathy’s idea, and it pulled us, all of us, into one place for two weeks, and then, when houses got more pricey, just the seven days–but the length didn’t really matter so much as the event itself. Cape Cod pulled us together with my great-aunt and second cousins, and made my best friend an unofficial Ashe cousin. It was family time.

My Papa was far from being a perfect person. But I couldn’t focus too much on the flaws because I got stuck thinking about my high school graduation and my college graduation. Papa came to both, and he came despite his ex-wife, my grandmother, being there too. They both put aside their decades-long differences to be there, and they would have done it again this summer when my oldest cousin graduated from her high school, and again in two years, and three years when the other girls graduated. I felt so special, loved, and important on those days. My cousins were cheated out of that feeling. It’s frustrating to think about, and starts the tears up again every time.

He talked to us about our futures and what we were going to do with our lives, or at least with the next few years. Cape Cod meant long discussions on the porch or at the kitchen table about colleges and choices. He was genuinely curious about our lives, and asked questions a journalist would be proud of. There was authority behind his voice, the authority that comes with age, but he trusted us to know enough to make our own decisions about everything and anything.

Sometimes he just told stories. I liked those the best. I wanted to tell stories, too.

Seventy-one is young. It’s too young, too young by about ten years. Maybe in some cases this isn’t so, maybe sometimes you expect the worst and can brace against the inevitable. I don’t know. In many ways, quickly leaving the world behind is the best way to go, despite the mark it leaves on the people who are still here.

It bears repeating that I know how fortunate I am, to have lived this long without feeling this kind of pain. I don’t take that things like that for granted. I thought I was too lucky; I was petrified of the day the other shoe would drop. And now it’s happened, and, like the damn SUV, I never saw it coming. And the pain hurts much more.

So what do you do? You talk to your family every day, to check in on everybody. You cry and you listen to Johnny Cash and you swear that somehow everything your Papa was is embodied in  Johnny’s low rumble as he finishes the title line in ‘When the Man Comes Around.” Somehow this makes sense to you, even if nothing else does. You purposefully start saying ‘passed away’ because it holds off the tears and you can’t break down in the J-Library, of all places. You write a long and indulgent blog post because you want people to know and you can’t send out a mass e-mail; that’s weird. You remember everything and cry some more, and you breathe relief at the knowledge that your family was overzealous about making vacation videos on Cape Cod, because you know you won’t ever forget the sound of his voice.

You recite Papa’s favorite story to yourself. It doesn’t take long.

I’ll tell you a story about Jack and Ory, and now my story’s begun.
I’ll tell you another about his brother, and now my story’s all done.

i love you.

8 Responses

  1. Your story reminds me about my Papa. He was just as amazing, and almost just as young. You got many more years than I did, though. I was only 17 but I miss him every single day. Some days will be better than others. Just remember how much he loved you and how special he made you feel, and he’ll always be with you. Now you’ve got *me* in tears. If you need hugs, come find me.

  2. This is a very lovely, touching tribute to your grandfather. When someone you love dies you experience a pain that is beyond description, it’s a pain that goes deeper than your bones and your nerves and seems to pass straight through your body and back again until it constricts you like a snake. My mother died when I was 16, she was 50. There isn’t a minute of any day that I don’t miss her or wish I could talk to her. Knowing what to say and what to call it gets easier and I promise that in time everything will get easier but it will take time. It’s been 5 years and I still have a hard time saying it out loud sometimes. I personally hate the term “loss”. Every time someone told me “I’m sorry for your loss” I wanted to punch them. I wasn’t careless with my mother, I didn’t misplace her like some ugly lunchbox on the playground at recess, she died. She fought a disease long and hard and in the end she couldn’t win and no one is to blame and she most certainly wasn’t lost. Your grandfather isn’t lost and he isn’t gone, he’ll be with you every second of every day and always will be.

  3. Dear Ivy,
    What a heartfelt, loving tribute you have written about Papa. It would take me months to write about the memories of almost fifty years with my Dad. I can tell you one of the first memories that your mother and I share: when our new sister was being born. Dad had the privilege of taking care of a five- and a four-year old girl. He made the following meals repeatedly for several days: scrambled eggs, pb&j sandwiches; and hamburgers. That was our diet until Mom and the new baby returned to our home. We survived and probably loved the food because we got to spend some time with our Dad who was often busy working. He also taught me how to throw a football spiral and I must say I am not bad at it even to this day. I love you very much, and I love him very much, too. Your Auntie Lisa

  4. Ivy,
    There will never be a more beautiful tribute written about him… He loved you beyond compare. And it shows…..

  5. Ivy, So filled with love you are…reading this story has brought tears to my eyes. You have all of my love dearest, Cate

  6. My darling Ivy: Your tribute to your grandfather, my former husband, floods me with memories. Did you know Norris and I met when we were just 15? He knew the words to my favorite song, “Stardust,” and sang beautifully. He was a laidback, big “Teddy Bear” of a kid.
    We were local kids, driving around Pittsfield, Maine, in Nana Ashe’s Woody wagon. While driving, Norris feigned that the car lights weren’t working. So we had a square dance in the street. But a nasty old neighbor called the local constable, who came to ask what we were doing. The guys wouldn’t tell who the girls were.
    The next day, Norris’s cousin, Claire Cianchette, met the boys at the town hall to keep them out of jail on charges of disturbing the peace. Pretty innocent stuff, but that was the beginning!
    We ran into each other again at the Pittsfield carnival a few years later, after Norris had recovered from a leg injury. It all began so many years ago, when we pledged our love for each other at 17…. Now, not a day goes by that I don’t realize how blessed I am to have you and our wonderful family!
    With love always, Nana

  7. Dearest Ivy,
    I have been asked the question many times by well meaning family members if I had read your tremendous tribute to my Dad, your Papa. Avoiding eye contact or any words of commitment on the subject, I would just mumble, head down that I knew all about it. Which I did. Not content necessarily, but how your words would sound and look when I could finally handle reading them. These 51 days later, I was finally ready. I chose to read your blog at work knowing that the surroundings would keep my tears in check…mostly. Over a small bowl of chicken curry and some falafel chips, I am now a member of the club. The club that knows what it feels like to loose someone you have known from your very first breath. One whose footsteps you could recognize anywhere. Whose smell was always wonderful. And whose eyes were the blue of a sea only imagined by sailors with a literary bent. You are brave and brilliant in your ability to define love in words. Thank you for sharing. I love you, Lorna

  8. Ivy,
    I read this when you first posted it, and I’ve probably read it a dozen times since then, whenever I feel extra lonely or lost in life. It reminds me of how lucky I am, in many ways, including being adopted as an honorary grandchild, and in life in general. And it brings back many beautiful memories as well, even though it leaves me with tears coursing down my face every time. It is a wonderful piece, and I thought you should know. Missing you, Tegan

Leave a Reply